Susan Granger’s review of “Dreamgirls” (Paramount Pictures)
“Dreamgirls,” about the trials and tribulations within a ’60s Motown trio modeled on the Supremes, could rival “Chicago” in the upcoming Oscar race. It’s that good!
When Effie White (Jennifer Hudson), Deena Jones (Beyonce Knowles) and Lorrell Robinson (Anika Noni Rose) make music together, it’s assumed that Effie will take the lead. She always has. But when their careers stall, despite singing backup for manic R&B artist James ‘Thunder’ Early (Eddie Murphy), ambitious, Svengali-like promoter Curtis Taylor Jr. (Jamie Foxx) elbows out their manager (Danny Glover) and revitalizes their sound, making Deena into a sleek soloist and pushing zaftig, soulful Effie into the background. With her brother C.C. (Keith Robinson) writing their songs, Effie’s justifiably angry and resentful, particularly since Curtis has become Deena’s lover. Kicked out of the group by consensus, brassy Effie is quickly replaced by compliant Michelle (Sharon Leal). The Dreamettes then go on to fame and fortune, while Effie’s left behind in Detroit. But there’s an emotional price to be paid.
Writer/director Bill Condon (“Chicago,” “Gods and Monsters,” “Kinsey”) heightens parallels with the Supremes by having Deena’s hairstyle, clothes and sound unmistakably Diana Ross’ – and Beyonce, of course, left Destiny’s Child to become a superstar. But it’s “American Idol” runner-up Jennifer Hudson – with her big, belting voice – who steals the show – and exuberant Eddie Murphy is a revelation.
The Broadway musical score by Henry Krieger and the late Tom Eyen works well, particularly with the addition of four new numbers. The soundtrack is simply sensational – and utilizing the relevant racial and socio-political context through newsreel footage is effective. Admittedly, there are character-development and transitional weaknesses, yet on the Granger Movie Gauge of 1 to 10, “Dreamgirls” is a dazzling 10 – one of the Best Pictures of 2006!
